Blogger Comments:
Here’s a preliminary mapping of the animal calls discussed in the article to Halliday’s protolanguage microfunctions. I’ve kept it at the level of illustrative examples rather than exhaustive coding.
| Species / Call | Observed Behaviour / Context | Microfunction | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bonobo: yelp–grunt | ‘Look at what I’m doing, let’s do this together’ (nest building) | Regulatory / Interactional | Coordinates joint activity; maintains social cohesion. |
| Bonobo: peep–whistle | ‘I would like to do this’ + ‘let’s stay together’ | Regulatory / Interactional | Encourages group alignment and peaceful coordination. |
| Chimpanzee: alarm–recruitment | Responding to snakes | Regulatory | Conveys threat and prompts group response; indicates environmental process. |
| Sperm whale: codas (a-vowel / i-vowel) | Communication via clicks, codas with frequency modulation | Personal / Interactional | Codas may indicate individual identity, social cues, or sequence patterns; precise “meaning” under investigation. |
| Japanese tit: alert + recruitment | Predator detection, approach behaviour | Regulatory | Combines information about environment and action; shows compositionality at microfunctional level. |
| Bengalese finch: song sequences (FinchGPT study) | Predictable song patterns | Interactional | Likely conveys social or territorial information; AI detects structure, not necessarily “meaning” in human sense. |
| Atlantic spotted dolphin: sequences (DolphinGemma) | Mimicked vocalisations | Interactional / Regulatory | Patterns generated for playback experiments; function in natural behaviour still uncertain. |
Key Observations Using Microfunctions
-
Coordination over grammar: The microfunctions highlight that animal communication primarily regulates behaviour and social relations.
-
Context-sensitive meaning: Each call’s significance emerges in specific environmental and social situations.
-
AI’s role: AI can detect patterns but does not assign microfunctions—it cannot yet perceive relational or contextual meaning.
